I would have enjoyed I KILL GIANTS a lot more if I didn't watch it last year preincarnated as A MONSTER CALLS. I tried so hard to judge it on its own but when the story is close to carbon copy it was difficult to manage. Of the two films I feel sorry for I KILL GIANTS, as a graphic novel it was released years before the A MONSTER CALLS novel. But on the film front A MONSTER CALLS released first and is a far superior movie into the imaginative escapism of grief.FULL REVIEW IS NOW UP ON SALTY POPCORN

Not as epic as I thought it would be (I didn't watch the trailer) from the title and movie poster, but a good drama none the less.

This movie was pretty good, but it was more of my family's type of movie than mine. I prefer actual fighting, whereas she ended up battling her inner demons.

LES QUELQUES ÉLÉMENTS FANTASTIQUES RAJOUTENT DE TRÈS BONNES IDÉES À UN FILM DÉJÀ PLUTÔT SURPRENANT. I KILL GIANTS S'AVÈRE UNE TRÈS BELLE SURPRISE ET C'EST ASSEZ DOMMAGE QUE LE FILM SERA MOINS VU QUE CE QU'IL NE LE MÉRITE VRAIMENT.

so basically shadow of the colossus

I didnt expect that.... WOW

I'm not usually in this position, but upon discovery of this trailer quite a few months ago, I was desperately awaiting the chance to see this movie. The concept itself intrigued me, but I had no idea that a novel was made of the same name. This is a property that quite honestly came out of nowhere to me. For these reasons, I looked at this as more of a fresh film concept, rather than an adaptation, but I feel that many viewers will feel the same as I do when thinking about the fact that it was a novel when watching the movie. Very ambitious in its storytelling and not afraid to show certain visual effects on a very low budget, here's why I Kill Giants is the type of movie that promises a lot but doesn't quite live up to those promises.Following young Barbara as she meets a new friend and continues to be bullied and made fun of in school for believing in giants, I Kill Giants is really just about whether or not they really do exist in this world. There is a much deeper meaning as to why she believes they exist, but I won't risk ruining the movie for anyone by diving into this aspect. Although a little stereotypical when it comes to their dialogue, everyone felt authentic to reality in terms of how their characters were written. Sadly, that positive is also a negative, because as I said, almost every secondary character feels shortchanged in terms of screen time and their overall characters are given just enough dialogue to show the type of people they are. This left much to be desired.Another thing that bothers me is that this premise is meant for a much larger scale in order to witness something grand when the movie calls for it. The fact that this is a low budget movie actually ruined certain aspects because it was clear that they were relying on Madison Wolfe's (Barbara) performance to distract you from not having to see what she's looking at. That being said, she is a terrific young actress and I was sucked into every emotional scene that she performed. I can't wait to see what she does next because I will absolutely support this actress in her future endeavors.I may seem to be talking about what aspects disappointed me quite a bit, but don't let that turn you off from watching this movie. Yes, the first act of the film rushes everyone's introduction and the second act feels rushed in order to make it to the climax, but that's where I just have to recommend this movie. The meaning behind everything brought tears to my eyes, so I have to commend the movie for pulling certain things off on an emotional level. It just disappointed me that everything leading up to certain reveals wasn't given enough attention and just felt forced as a result.In the end, the concept of this film is fantastic and could've been an amazing film with a bigger budget and a slightly different tone. I give the movie props for trying to pull off certain imagery with such a low budget and many of the performances were great as well. I particularly enjoyed Barbara's interaction with her guidance counsellor Mrs. Mollé, played very well by Zoe Saldana. The third act of this movie makes it worth watching for sure, so yes, I would recommend this movie to film fans, but I just have to warn you that you may see certain things coming, because certain things are sort of spoon-fed to you throughout the second act in order to make time for reveals. I Kill Giants is an impressive concept with a very uneven execution.

Very surprising gem of a movie! Loved this movie, good for any audience. A heroine for any child to see.

LOVE IT WHEN THEY ADAPT A ANIME OR COMIC BOOK, LIKE THE COMIC OR ANIME, WHEN THEY CHANGE IT FROM THE ORIGINAL IT USUALLY SUCKS THIS ONE DID NOT!

An interesting movie, professionally, but after I've seen so many similar ones, I did not enjoy this one at all.

I'm not sure how to describe this film without giving everything away. Its simply brilliant, the lead is just a complete joy to watch and she will have you laughing out loud on very regular basis. And this isn't some light tween movie, it deals with heavy subject matter in a very respectful and conscientious way which will have you in tears by the end. I suppose it's half fantasy and half coming of age drama, and has parallels to the like of Stand by me, only minus the 50's nostalgia. With that film in mind, you might understand why 79% is criminal in my opinion, how a quiet place with its multitude of movie sins gets 100% is nonsensical. This is a breakthrough performance for the leading lady and deserves far more credit on here than its getting.

an emotional ride with sweet message that hits right in the core. A very underrated film of 2018

Strong acting and story, but I liked it better when it was called A Monster Calls.

Rarely do i feel compelled to comment on a movie - this is a brilliant film on so many levels. The acting is superb - the plot connects very deeply - and it has some strong messages as well.

The last 10 minutes....oof. Killer.